Written by: Stuart Leibiger, La Salle University
By the end of this section, you will:
- Explain how various factors contributed to the American victory in the Revolution
- Use this Decision Point after the Washington Crossing the Delaware and The Battle of Saratoga and the French Alliance Narratives.
As George Washington entered the Temple of Virtue at Newburgh, New York, he knew the fate of the American Revolution hung in the balance. Continental Army soldiers had constructed the temple of logs to provide a space for the officers to meet and socialize. But on the afternoon of March 15, 1783, the officers’ mood was neither cheerful nor festive. Instead, they were angry.
Two years after the victory at Yorktown, the officers were frustrated by the treatment they had received from the Confederation Congress, the governing body under the Articles of Confederation that had been ratified in 1781. The Confederation Congress had not paid some of them in months—others, years—nor guaranteed them pensions once the war ended. Their patience with the government had run out. Several officers serving under General Horatio Gates threatened to use the army to seize control of the country, ruling by military force to redress their grievances and achieve justice. If the commander in chief would not lead the way, he would simply have to be cast aside in favor of a leader who would place the army’s needs first. Well aware of the hostile audience he would face, Washington made sure he had his spectacles with him. He had difficulty reading even his own handwriting without them.
Trouble had begun five days earlier. On March 10, an anonymous address (secretly written by Major John Armstrong, one of Gates’s aides) had circulated through camp, calling the officers to meet the next day to answer “a country that tramples upon your rights, disdains your cries, and insults your distress.” The announcement suggested the army should defy Congress and launch a military takeover (or “coup”). At that moment, the chance of victory for the Revolution might have been squandered and republican government replaced by tyranny.
Washington understood that the army’s grievances were legitimate and its patience worn thin. Congress’s neglect of the army stemmed from its own bankruptcy. Under the Articles of Confederation, Congress lacked the power to tax. Congress assessed taxes on the states, but they frequently refused to pay because Congress had no power to compel them. But there was more behind Congress’s treatment of the army than insolvency. Revolutionary Americans distrusted permanent, professional armies—what they called “standing armies.” Armies were seen as instruments of tyranny, and generals as potential tyrants or dictators.
Recognizing his countrymen’s fears and dedicated to the republican ideal of patriotically serving the republic, Washington had never abused the military power given to him as commander in chief. He had resisted the temptation to use the army as his personal bodyguard, to make himself a dictator—to become a Caesar. Instead, he had remained faithful to republican government, to the rule of the people through their elected representatives, and he deferred to Congress even when it impeded the war effort. Therefore, Washington immediately decided to quell the incipient uprising if possible. Seizing the initiative, he shrewdly called a gathering on March 15, hoping to appease the men and avert a coup. Although he did not reveal that he would attend, Washington secretly resolved to meet his disgruntled officers in person, face to face, to either stand them down or be deposed.
Not announcing his attendance proved a clever move. Before Washington’s arrival, the gathering elected Gates the presiding officer, which barred him from taking an active role in the deliberations. When the “visibly agitated” Washington strode into the hall, he took the floor and gravely spoke to the tense, unruly audience in the overcrowded assembly hall. He begged the officers not to take a step that would bury their reputations in infamy. What evil could the author of the anonymous address have been up to? he asked. “Can he be a friend to this Country? Rather, is he not an insidious Foe . . . sowing the seeds of discord and separation between the Civil and Military powers of the Continent?”
Despite his eloquent and impassioned speech, Washington’s arguments fell on deaf ears: The men were unmoved. The commander concluded his remarks by saying he would read a letter from a member of Congress promising justice to the officers. Hostile murmurs welled up in the audience as Washington struggled to read the letter. Eyewitness Samuel Shaw described the scene:
[Washington] stood single and alone. There was no saying where the passions of an army, which were not a little inflamed, might lead. . . . Under these circumstances he appeared, not at the head of his troops, but as it were in opposition to them, and for a dreadful moment the interests of the army and its General seemed to be in competition.
But Washington subdued the malcontents with a dramatic gesture: He pulled out his glasses, which no one had ever seen him wear in public before. Putting them on, he remarked, “Gentlemen, you must pardon me. I have grown gray in your service and now find myself growing blind.” His poignant admission of weakness shattered the impending mutiny and left many of the officers in tears. Washington’s statement reminded them of all he had sacrificed. He had been with the army almost since the start of the war. He had exposed himself to every hardship and danger. He too had served without pay and had risked everything for what he called “the glorious cause.” Never before had he seemed so big—or had they felt so small.
Whether his dramatic gesture was spontaneous or staged, it worked. After Washington left the room, the officers unanimously rejected a military coup and pledged to conduct peaceful negotiations with Congress. The new nation had survived its brush with military despotism.
Once the war was over and independence won, Washington believed his job to be complete. He resigned as commander and retired to his Mount Vernon plantation. Upon learning that he had voluntarily surrendered his power to the sovereign people, King George III is said to have pronounced Washington “the greatest character of the age.” Ironically, by never abusing his power and by giving it back to the people, Washington actually became more powerful. He won the trust of his fellow citizens, who repeatedly called for his services, not only as commander in chief but also as president of the 1787 Constitutional Convention and, finally, from 1789 to 1797, as president of the United States.
Washington’s contemporaries understood that he embodied classical republican virtue. A statue commissioned from French sculptor Jean Antoine Houdon and completed in 1791–1792 now stands in the state capitol in Richmond, Virginia. It shows Washington not as a military victor but as an American version of the Roman general Cincinnatus, retiring from the army, hanging up his military cloak and sword, and going back to his plow. Similarly, John Trumbull’s painting, which hangs in the U.S. Capitol rotunda, shows Washington standing before Congress, resigning his military commission, and becoming an ordinary citizen again.
The American Revolution is unusual among modern world revolutions because it did not end in a dictatorship—as did the French, Russian, and Chinese revolutions. That it led instead to the formation of a republic had much to do with Washington’s careful exercise of power and repeated surrender of that power back to the republic. As Thomas Jefferson remarked, “the moderation and virtue of a single character has probably prevented this revolution from being closed as most others have been by a subversion of that liberty it was intended to establish.” Simply put, Washington laid down a cornerstone of U.S. constitutionalism: The military is always subordinate to the republican civilian government.
Washington acted virtuously, putting the public good first, in part because he believed in the idea of an American republic and wanted to be known in the hearts and minds of the people as a servant of that republic. He wanted to be a military leader and statesman unlike any other in modern world history. To do that, he had to walk away from power and not give in to its temptations. Without an “indispensable man” like Washington, the new nation’s experiment in republican government might never have succeeded.
1. Which of the following best describes why Continental Army officers were angry and threatening to rebel against their leadership?
- Washington had made a tactical error that resulted in huge losses for the Continental Army.
- The officers believed the Confederation Congress was acting tyrannically by placing executive power in Washington’s hands.
- The officers had neither been paid as promised by the Confederation Congress nor were they guaranteed pay once the war ended.
- Congress was imposing harsh taxes, so they wanted Washington to take control of the government as a military dictator.
2. What important constitutional precedent did Washington establish at Newburgh?
- Military subordination to civilian control
- Military experience in leadership
- Executive subordination to Congress
- Election of military commanders
3. Which of the following was an immediate cause of the growing unrest among Washington’s troops?
- An anonymous address calling for a military coup had circulated throughout the camp.
- Washington punished his men for poor performance on the field, demoralizing them.
- Alexander Hamilton gave a fiery speech inspiring troops to overthrow the ineffective tyranny of Congress.
- Covert British actions led many troops to believe they would receive amnesty for their actions if they toppled the standing civic structure of the colonies.
4. Which of the following best provides context for explaining why American Revolutionaries distrusted standing armies?
- Washington’s leadership throughout the Revolution was excessively cruel and deceptive.
- Instances of betrayal, like that of Benedict Arnold, eroded trust among the military and, ultimately, the public as well.
- A variety of historical examples of armies overthrowing republican governments created suspicion of a standing army.
- The egalitarian nature of the army was entirely new for the colonies and it weakened their unity.
5. How did the attempted military coup of 1783 ultimately end?
- Ranking officers garnered enough support from their troops to sequester the aging Washington and take control from Congress.
- Washington’s display of sacrifice and humility dissipated the tension and resulted in even greater respect for the commander in chief.
- Each officer who participated in the circulation of the address was identified and executed, setting an example for any who might have considered further action.
- A messenger dispatched to the Continental Congress convinced them to capitulate to the pleas of the soldiers with immediate paychecks and supplies.
6. Which of the following actions sealed Washington’s character as one of republican virtue?
- Successful overthrow of the Continental Congress at the request of his highest-ranking officers
- Victory over British General Cornwallis at Yorktown, Virginia
- Peaceful transfer of power from commander in chief of the military to the legislative ruling body of the new nation
- Inclusion of multiple classes and ethnicities within the ranks of his army
7. Which of the following describes republican virtue?
- The ideology of small government that protects the rights of individuals by interfering as little as possible
- Faithful adherence to the civic duties of government in an ethical and principled manner even at personal sacrifice
- Strict adherence to fulfilling the wishes of constituents, regardless of personal beliefs
- Allegiance to the monarchy because of Britain’s economic superiority and promise of military protection
Free Response Questions
- Do you think Washington’s dramatic gesture of putting on his glasses was planned or spontaneous? How does your answer conform to what we know about Washington’s character?
- Explain how Washington’s actions helped to reinforce the United States’ development as a republic.
- One historian claims that Washington acted “virtuously putting the public good first, in part because he believed in the idea of an American republic and wanted to be known in the hearts and minds of the people as a servant of that republic.” Do you agree with this interpretation? Explain.
- What do you think would have happened to the United States had Washington been unable to prevent a military overthrow of the civilian government?
AP Practice Questions
“I cannot, in justice to my own belief, & what I have great reason to conceive is the intention of Congress, conclude this Address, without giving it as my decided opinion; that that Honble Body, entertain exalted sentiments of the Services of the Army; and, from a full conviction of its Merits & sufferings, will do it compleat Justice: That their endeavors, to discover & establish funds for this purpose, have been unwearied, and will not cease, till they have succeeded, I have not a doubt. But, like all other large Bodies, where there is a variety of different Interests to reconcile, their deliberations are slow. Why then should we distrust them? And, in consequence of that distrust, adopt measures, which may cast a shade over that glory which, has been so justly acquired; and tarnish the reputation of an Army which is celebrated thro’ all Europe, for its fortitude and Patriotism? And for what is this done? To bring the object we seek for nearer? No! Most certainly, in my opinion, it will cast it at a greater distance.”
Newburgh Address: George Washington to Officers of the Army, March 15, 1783Refer to the excerpt provided.
1. In his Newburgh speech, Washington highlighted which of the following major weaknesses of the Confederation Congress?
- The Congress represented too many interests.
- The Congress lacked efficiency.
- The Congress was slow to raise money from taxes and duties.
- The Congress did not value the army’s contributions to the cause of independence.
2. In his speech at Newburgh, Washington assured his army that
- Congress was an evil entity stripping men of their liberties.
- Congress was attempting to build an “Empire of Blood” with a standing army.
- He was commander in chief and as such would ensure that a standing army was established.
- Congress would eventually pay the men, and no man or institution had the right to strip men of their liberties.
“For myself (and I take no merit in giving the assurance, being induced to it from principles of gratitude, veracity & justice)—a grateful sence of the confidence you have ever placed in me—a recollection of the Chearful assistance, & prompt obedience I have experienced from you, under every vicisitude of Fortune, and the sincere affection I feel for an Army, I have so long had the honor to Command, will oblige me to declare, in this public & solemn manner, that, in the attainment of compleat justice for all your toils & dangers, and in the gratification of every wish, so far as may be done consistently with the great duty I owe my Country, and those powers we are bound to respect, you may freely command my services to the utmost of my abilities.”
Newburgh Address: George Washington to Officers of the Army, March 15, 1783Refer to the excerpt provided.
3. Which of the following best describes the way Washington viewed the Newburgh conspiracy?
- He was understanding and sympathetic toward the disgruntled soldiers.
- He was angry and swore retribution against the conspirators.
- He was hurt and felt detached from the rest of the men.
- He was condescending to soldiers and defensive of Congress.
4. Which of the following best describes the significance of Washington’s actions at Newburgh?
- Washington ensured that the United States would not have a revolution that ended in military dictatorship.
- Washington demonstrated that a free people had nothing to fear from standing armies.
- Washington proved that Congress held most of the power in the new government.
- Washington motivated soldiers from across the Union to unite under his leadership, forging a national identity.
5. The event depicted in the image provided challenged what prevailing norm of the time?
- A military leader kept control after the conflict was over.
- Battles were fought according to strict rules in an open space.
- Women were not allowed in public buildings on their own.
- Military officers received a triumphant welcome.
6. The action in the image provided most directly caused
- a swell of patriotism and trust in Washington as a virtuous leader
- a military coup whereby Washington took over as dictator
- the French alliance, which supported the Americans with financial and military supplies
- the formation of a new government that would address the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation
Washington, George. “Newburgh Address: George Washington to Officers of the Army, March 15, 1783.” Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association. http://www.mountvernon.org/education/primary-sources-2/article/newburgh-address-george-washington-to-officers-of-the-army-march-15-1783/
Fowler, William M., Jr. American Crisis: George Washington and the Dangerous Two Years After Yorktown, 1781–1783. New York: Walker Books, 2011.
Head, David. A Crisis of Peace: George Washington, the Newburgh Conspiracy, and the Fate of the American Revolution. New York: Pegasus Books, 2019.
Knott, Stephen F., and Tony Williams. Washington and Hamilton: The Alliance that Forged America. Naperville: Sourcebooks, 2015.
Kohn, Richard H. Eagle and Sword: The Federalists and the Creation of the Military Establishment in America, 1783–1802. New York: Free Press, 1975.
Leibiger, Stuart. Founding Friendship: George Washington, James Madison, and the Creation of the American Republic. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1999.