Lesson
The Lost Promise of Reconstruction and Rise of Jim Crow, 1860-1896

Founding Principles
Representative / Republican Government, Equal Protection, Equality, Liberty
Virtues
Guiding Question:
To what extent did Founding principles of liberty, equality, and justice become a reality for African Americans from Reconstruction to the end of the nineteenth century?
Objectives:
Students will analyze the application of the Founding principles of liberty, justice, and equality from Reconstruction to Plessy v. Ferguson (1865–1896) by:
- Analyzing ideas and actions regarding slavery in primary source documents
– Examining the ways in which legislation and policy, the courts, and individuals and groups were complementary in the quest to end slavery and the ways in which these agents of change were in conflict
– Considering the effectiveness of appeals to end slavery based upon moral purity and the civic virtue of prudence - Students will reflect on ideas, institutions, and individuals in history in order to decide how they might apply the lessons gleaned from this period to today.
Note that the Attacking the Freedmen’s Bureau poster in this lesson would be considered offensive or derogatory today. This image has been retained in its original form in order to present it accurately in its historical context for student learning, including understanding why it is not acceptable today.
Materials
- Anticipate: Image Analysis “Is this a republican form of government? Is this protecting life, liberty, or property? Is this the equal protection of the laws?”, Thomas Nast, 1876
- Introductory Essay: The Lost Promise of Reconstruction and Rise of Jim Crow, 1860-1896
- Graphic Organizer, Primary Sources in Lesson 3
- Concluding Analysis, Lesson 3
- Answer Key, Lesson 3
Lesson Components


Lesson plan
More Information
The following lesson asks students to look at primary source documents as they consider the following question: To what extent did Founding principles of liberty, equality, and justice become a reality for African Americans from Reconstruction to the end of the nineteenth century? The Civil War ended slavery and African Americans were in a position to claim their natural rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. But would that happen?
The documents come from a variety of actors in the American republic: legislators and policymakers, the courts, and individuals and groups. As students go through the documents, encourage them to think not only about the principles of liberty, equality, and justice, but also about the way in which these groups interact with each other in creating or stalling change.
The main activity in this lesson requires students to conduct primary source analysis. Two sets of primary sources are included with this lesson: a longer set and an abbreviated set. The abbreviated documents have been selected for learners with lower reading levels or for classes wishing to explore the guiding questions for this lesson that cannot dedicate as much time to it. Questions have been provided for each primary source. Teachers may choose to use the provided questions as scaffolds for students or remove them as best suits their teaching situation. Graphic organizers have been provided to use as an additional tool alongside the questions accompanying each document or in place of them.
For primary source analysis, students may work individually, in pairs, or in small groups as best fits your classroom. Additionally, primary sources can serve as the basis for a stations or jigsaw activity.














