Skip to Main Content

Should the United States Congress Codify Same-Sex Marriage?

96.8% yes
3.2% no

In the 2015 case of Obergefell v. Hodges, the Supreme Court ruled that the Fourteenth Amendment protects the right of same-sex couples to marry. Now, some are encouraging Congress to pass a law that would codify this right in order to strengthen its protections. The current lame duck Congress is set to vote on this bill before its successors’s new term begins.  

Those who argue that the United States Congress should codify same-sex marriage argue that doing so is essential to protecting the rights of same-sex couples. They argue that the Supreme Court could choose to reconsider its ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges, and it could overturn it like it recently overturned Roe v. Wade. This side may argue that same-sex marriage ought to be protected so that same-sex couples can enjoy the same rights and privileges as heterosexual couples.  

Those who argue that the United States Congress should not codify same-sex marriage argue that doing so undermines traditional marriage. They argue that until very recently, societies have viewed marriage as an institution between a man and a woman. Changing that, they argue, is detrimental to communities as a whole. Some may also argue that codifying same-sex marriage is unnecessary because of the Supreme Court’s ruling in Obergefell 

So, what do you think? Should the United States Congress Codify Same-Sex Marriage? Students can answer Yes, it should; No, it should not; or a nuanced answer in between! Be sure to submit your answers by December 14th to have a chance at winning this week’s competition. 


Reading materials


Current Standings

Taylor from Montana voted yes

Folks should be allowed to marry whoever they want. Heterosexual or Homosexual, marriages don’t affect people on a broad scale; it won’t kill someone in one state to know that…

Seamus from Massachusetts voted no

No

Luke from Montana voted yes

I think they should i dont care who you wanna marry as long as you dont wanna try and force it on me.

Jack from Illinois voted no

I believe that the United States Congress should not codify same-sex marriage. First of all I am a Roman Catholic which means I follow very traditional ideas. Up until recently,…

Pierson from Georgia voted yes

Yes, they should. Everybody saying that "same-sex marriage is already legal, so we don't need to codify it" is sorely wrong. Even if it is technically legal, it still isn't…

Liam from Illinois voted no

I think this would be very unnecessary while there is more important things to worry about.

Alexis from Montana voted yes

i believe same sex marriage should be legal and everyone should be supportive of it, same sex marriage is the same thing as a marriage between a man and women…

Cj from Illinois voted no

I think that everyone should be able to love who they would like to But, I think, if you love someone you don’t have to marry them to show your…

Gavin from Massachusetts voted yes1 reply

Why does gay marraige bother the homophobes so much? Why do they care?

Justin from Idaho voted no2 replies

Not all states and cultures need same sex marriages


Recent debates