August Landmesser’s Courageous Refusal45 min
- What is the cost of civil disobedience?
- What is the significance of courage in a society built on democratic principles?
- What are we willing to do in reaction to something we see as unjust when surrounded by those that are not resisting?
- Is it reasonable to expect resistance when the cost is high?
- Students will consider the cost of courageously opposing those in power.
- Students will have an important discussion, based on a thought exercise of what we think about character, courage and standing up for a right.
- Courage Primary Source Analysis: The Landmesser Picture (Provide copies or project on large screen.)
- Courage: August Landmesser’s Courageous Refusal Essay
- Discussion Guide – August Landmesser’s Courageous Refusal
- From Where I Stood to Where I Stand
- Virtue in Action: August Landmesser’s Courageous Refusal
- Courage Worksheet
Benz, Wolfgang. A Concise History of the Third Reich. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2006.
Wiesel, Elie. Night. New York: Hill and Wang, 2006.
In order to understand the risks that August Landmesser took, students will need some background in Nazi rule of Germany, especially as related to the race laws that existed there in 1936, the date of the photo to be examined. People were expected to turn in and inform on people who resisted Nazi rule in any way.
Post and point out this question in the classroom: What is the significance of courage in a society built on democratic principles?
Gather students in a hallway, a gym, or a classroom in which you can create a clear path from one side to the other. Identify one end of the hallway (or room) as “strongly agree” and the opposite end as “strongly disagree.” Describe the space between those two ends as the continuum between those two positions, and identify a defined midpoint. Explain that you are going to read a series of statements, that students will listen to each entire statement and then, on your cue (Suggested cue: Say, “Choose a position and take your stand.”), choose a position and to go stand at the spot on the continuum or on either end, that represents his or her position: “Strongly Agree,” “Strongly Disagree,”… or somewhere in between.
Read each of the following statements, allowing time for students to choose and move to a position, to note their positions in relation to the entire continuum, and for you to note their positions in relation to each other. Do not make direct comments; just read the statements and allow students time to decide on, and move to, their positions. (It is likely that many students will agree, to some degree, with each statement.)
- Statement 1: “Judge not, lest you be judged.”—Then the cue: “Choose a position and take your stand.”
- Statement 2: “People in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones.”—Then the cue to move.
- Statement 3: “All that is needed for evil to triumph is for good people to do nothing.”—Then the cue to move.
Without commentary, but while acknowledging and encouraging student comments, return to the classroom and direct students to their seats.
Distribute the Courage Primary Source Analysis handout or project the photo on classroom screen. Conduct a close-reading of the photo, referring to the questions on the handout and allowing for additional discussion.
Distribute copies of August Landmesser’s Courageous Refusal Essay. Have students read the essay with a partner or in small groups and answer the questions on the Discussion Guide.
Distribute the From Where I Stood to Where I Stand handout. Make sure each student has two different colors of pen or pencil. Have each student indicate, in one color, the “hallway position” they chose for each statement. Then, with the second color pen or pencil, have them indicate the position they would take after considering August Landmesser’s story. Discuss why students initially chose the positions that they did, and if they changed positions after considering Landmesser’s story, why they did so.
Discuss the following:
- Do the first two statements mean that one should keep silent in the face of evil? Why do you think so?
- Does the third statement mean that we should judge the actions of others? How do you know?
- How, if at all, can the contradictory ideas in the previous two questions be reconciled? (That is, the idea that on the one hand, we shouldn’t ever judge others, but on the other hand, that we should take action against injustice.)
- Are there times when judgment is required in order to take a just action?
The real “learning moment” would come with bringing the Landmesser picture back up and discuss where students moved. Do they see a comparison between their choices and August’s choice? That if they knew moving in the “positive” direction had a personal cost, would they still take it?
Ask students to think about these questions, but not necessarily to respond out loud: What is the significance of courage in a society built on democratic principles? What is your personal response to situations requiring courage?
Distribute the Courage Worksheet and have students write their personal response to Landmesser’s demonstration of courage.
Read the dialogue below and answer the following questions:
- How does this scene relate to the photo of Landmesser?
- What does the German Old Man mean by “There are always men like you”?
- Are there, in fact, always people like the German Old Man? Explain.
The Avengers (2012) Dialogue
Loki: Kneel before me. I said, KNEEL!
[everyone becomes quiet and kneels before him]
Loki: Is not this simpler? Is this not your natural state? It’s the unspoken truth of humanity, that you crave subjugation. The bright lure of freedom diminishes your life’s joy in a mad scramble for power, for identity. You were made to be ruled. In the end, you will always kneel.
German Old Man: [defiantly rises] Not to men like you!
Loki: There are no men like me.
German Old Man: There are ALWAYS men like you!
The Self-Deception of Irma Grese
In this lesson, students explore the problem of self-deception in the context of the World War II Holocaust. They consider how ordinary men and women can be indoctrinated to commit inhuman evil, and discuss how we can guard against ideologies that lead to these behaviors.
The Unknown Rebel’s Courage at Tiananmen Square
An exploration of the virtue of courage using the example of an anonymous individual who refused to yield to a tank during the crackdown on protesters at Tiananmen Square.
Courage Under Fire: The Selfless Decision of John Robert Fox
In this lesson, students will learn about the actions of John Robert Fox during the Italian campaign during World War II. Through his example, students will understand how they can act more selflessly in their own lives.